Buffalo → Florida Relocation Guide
Moving from Buffalo to Florida
What changes for Buffalo buyers in Orlando and Central Florida
Buffalo gives you real neighborhoods, wings done right and some of the most affordable houses in the Northeast. Orlando and Central Florida cost more per square foot, but they trade lake-effect snow for a winter spent outdoors, with no state income tax.
Updated November 2026 · By Ryan Solberg, Broker/Owner and licensed Mortgage Loan Originator (NMLS #1784218)
Quick Read
Is moving from Buffalo to Florida worth it?
Often yes, if you keep your income. You drop New York income tax and the long heating season, and Orlando or Central Florida offers newer homes with pools and garages. The honest catch is that Buffalo houses are cheaper, so expect to spend more on the home and on insurance, and the math works best with remote work, a transfer or retirement income.
Your Buffalo house buys less in Orlando. Your paycheck goes further.
New York taxes income at up to 10.9%, and many Erie County towns carry property tax bills well above Florida's ~0.8% average rate.
Side by Side
Buffalo vs. Florida: taxes, home prices and cost of living.
| New York / Buffalo | Florida / Orlando | |
|---|---|---|
| State income tax | Up to 10.9% | 0% |
| Typical home price | ~$260K median (Erie County) | ~$445K Orlando metro median |
| Avg property tax rate | ~1.3% | ~0.8% (homestead cap +3%/yr) |
| Avg homeowners insurance (NAIC 2023) | $1,801/yr | $2,779/yr statewide |
| Florida homestead exemption | — | Up to $51K exemption (2026) + 3%/yr cap; larger from 2027 |
| Average January high | 32°F | 72°F |
| Winter | Lake-effect storms, roughly 90+ in. of snow | Sunny dry season, highs in the 70s |
| Housing stock | Much of the city's housing built before 1940 | Much of it 1980s or newer, often concrete block |
| Typical commute | I-90, the 33 and the 190 in snow season | 20–40 min outside I-4 and 408 peaks |
Tax figures are 2026 state rates and approximate averages, not tax advice. Your numbers depend on residency, income type and county. Confirm with your CPA. Insurance figures are NAIC's 2023 state averages for standard homeowners policies; 2026 quotes are often higher and depend mostly on roof age, construction and location.
Florida's homestead exemption
For 2026, Florida's homestead exemption takes up to $51,411 off a primary residence's assessed value for non-school taxes ($25,000 for school taxes), and Save Our Homes caps yearly increases in assessed value at 3% or inflation, whichever is lower. Voters approved Amendment 3 on November 3, 2026 (about 62% in unofficial returns). From 2027 it raises the non-school exemption to as much as $150,000, and $250,000 in 2028, for owners who were permanent Florida residents by December 31, 2026. People who become residents later start with $50,000 off non-school taxes and qualify for the larger amount from their fifth year of exemption. The Legislature still has to pass the rules that carry this out, so confirm the details with your county property appraiser.
Purchasing Power
What your budget buys: Buffalo vs. Orlando.
Western New York
$300,000
A 1950s Cape in Kenmore, Tonawanda or Cheektowaga, or a city double in North Buffalo with an upstairs unit to rent.
$450,000
A 4-bedroom Colonial in Orchard Park, Hamburg or Amherst, usually 1970s–90s, with plenty of garage space for the snow gear.
$700,000
A larger newer home in Clarence or East Amherst, or one of the big old houses in the Elmwood Village or Parkside.
Central Florida / Orlando
$300,000
A 1980s–90s 3-bedroom block home in Apopka, roughly 1,400–1,700 sq ft, about 25 minutes from downtown Orlando.
$450,000
A newer 4-bedroom, 2,200–2,500 sq ft home in St. Cloud or Clermont with a community pool, or a smaller pool home on an established street.
$700,000
A 3,000+ sq ft pool home in Winter Garden near Plant Street and the West Orange Trail, or a renovated bungalow in College Park.
Free 20-Minute Call
Planning a move from Buffalo? Let's talk it through.
One call, no pressure. You tell me your budget, your timeline and how you want to live. I tell you which Central Florida areas fit, what homes there cost right now, and what the monthly payment would look like.
- A short list of neighborhoods matched to how you live in Buffalo.
- Real numbers: prices, taxes, insurance and payment.
- A plan for buying remotely, and for the mortgage if you need one.
Prefer to talk now?
321.373.3536Request your relocation call
I'll call or text you within one business day to set a time.
The Honest Version
Pros and cons of moving from Buffalo to Florida.
What gets better
- No state income tax, compared with New York's graduated rates of up to 10.9%.
- Florida's average property tax rate is about 0.8%, against about 1.3% across New York and often more in Erie County towns.
- No snow blower, roof rakes or salt-damaged cars, and November through April is Central Florida's best weather.
- Much of Central Florida's housing is 1980s or newer, often concrete block, instead of a century-old Buffalo double with original systems.
- The Blue Jays, parent club of the Buffalo Bisons, hold spring training in Dunedin, about two hours from Orlando.
What to go in clear-eyed about
- The same budget buys less house than in Erie County, so your Buffalo sale may not cover a Florida purchase outright.
- Homeowners insurance averaged $2,779 a year in Florida in NAIC's 2023 data, against $1,801 in New York.
- June through September brings highs around 90°F, heavy humidity and almost daily afternoon thunderstorms.
- Pay in some Orlando fields, where tourism is the largest industry, can run below Western New York's, so compare any job offer against your current pay.
- Newer subdivisions often carry HOA dues and CDD assessments that most Buffalo suburbs don't have.
Expert Perspective
The straight talk I give Buffalo buyers.
I'll be direct with you: if you're selling in Buffalo, your money won't stretch further on the house itself. Western New York is one of the places where Central Florida prices usually run higher than what you're selling. The savings show up in taxes, upkeep and how you spend six months of the year.
Here's how that math usually works. New York's income tax goes away, and so does a suburban Erie County school and town tax bill that often runs well above Florida rates. Your heating bill, snow removal and ice-dam repairs fall off too. Homeowners insurance goes up, and summer air conditioning replaces winter heat. I put all of it on one page so you can see the net.
Buffalo buyers tend to want either a real neighborhood or a lot of house. If you love the Elmwood Village, look at College Park, where you can walk to dinner five minutes from downtown Orlando. If you want the most square footage for the money, Clermont and St. Cloud are where I'd start.
You also keep a thread back home. The Blue Jays, the Bisons' parent club, train in Dunedin every spring, and Orlando International has nonstop flights to BUF for the holidays and Bills weekends.

Ryan Solberg — MaxLife Realty
Neighborhood Matching
Best places to live in Central Florida for Buffalo transplants.
Estimated drive times and typical single-family price ranges.
| Neighborhood | Drive | Typical price | Buffalo comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| College Park | 10 min to downtown Orlando | $500K–$1.2M | Walkable and older, like the Elmwood Village |
| Winter Garden | 30 min to downtown Orlando | $450K–$900K | A village center, like East Aurora |
| Clermont | 40 min to downtown Orlando | $380K–$700K | More land and room, like Clarence |
| St. Cloud | 40 min to downtown Orlando | $350K–$550K | Water nearby and more room, like Grand Island |
College Park
Walkable and older, like the Elmwood VillageBrick streets, 1920s–40s bungalows and a main street of local cafes along Edgewater Drive. It's the closest thing in Orlando to an old-city neighborhood you can walk, about 10 minutes from downtown.
Homes and prices in College Park →Winter Garden
A village center, like East AuroraA small-town downtown on Plant Street with a Saturday farmers market and the West Orange Trail running through it. Newer subdivisions with community pools ring the historic core.
Homes and prices in Winter Garden →Clermont
More land and room, like ClarenceRolling hills, which are rare in Florida, plus chain-of-lakes boating and more house per dollar than most of Orlando's west side. About 40 minutes from downtown.
Homes and prices in Clermont →St. Cloud
Water nearby and more room, like Grand IslandA small lakefront town on East Lake Tohopekaliga with newer subdivisions, lower prices and an easy run to Lake Nona and Orlando International.
Homes and prices in St. Cloud →Not sure which area fits? I'll narrow it down with you in one call.
The Move Itself
Buffalo to Orlando: getting there and settling in.
- Driving distance
- ~1,170 miles
- Drive time
- ~17–18 hrs (2 days)
- Flight, BUF to MCO
- ~2 hrs 40 min nonstop
How much does it cost to move from Buffalo to Florida?
Buffalo to Orlando is about 1,170 miles. Based on 2025–2026 published moving guides, a full-service move of a 2–3 bedroom home typically runs roughly $3,000 to $8,500. A portable container is about $3,000 to $5,500, and a rental truck with fuel about $1,200 to $3,500. How much you ship, the season and access at both homes move the price most, and moves into Florida are often priced differently from moves out.
Your Buffalo-to-Florida move checklist
- Get insurance quotes (homeowners, and flood where relevant) on your shortlist before the inspection period ends. Roof age and construction type drive the price.
- Book movers 6–8 weeks ahead. Late spring and summer are peak season and cost more.
- Get your Florida driver's license within 30 days of becoming a resident. Before you register a car, buy Florida auto insurance (PIP and property damage liability) and have the VIN verified; then title and register it within 10 days of starting a Florida job or enrolling kids in school. Expect a one-time $225 fee for a vehicle new to Florida.
- Register to vote in Florida and consider filing a Declaration of Domicile with the county clerk.
- Own the home and live in it as your permanent residence on January 1, then file for the homestead exemption with the county property appraiser by March 1. Florida voters approved Amendment 3 in November 2026: people who are permanent Florida residents by December 31, 2026 can qualify for a much larger homestead exemption from 2027. If you can establish residency before year-end, ask about it now.
- File a part-year New York return for the year you move, and keep records that show when you left: closing statement, lease end, utility shutoffs.
Buying From Out of State
Buying in Florida while you still live in Buffalo.
Can I get a Florida mortgage while I still live in Buffalo?
Yes. A loan originator has to be licensed where the home being financed is, not where you live today. I'm licensed to originate loans on Florida homes (NMLS #1784218), so you can apply from Buffalo. Any loan on your current New York home would go through a lender licensed in New York, and I'll coordinate timing with them. You can check any originator's licenses on NMLS Consumer Access.
Do I have to sell my Buffalo home before I buy in Florida?
No, but the timing needs a plan. If your current home hasn't sold and closed, lenders usually count both housing payments when qualifying you. Once you have a signed sale contract and the buyer's financing contingencies have cleared, some loan types can leave the old payment out. The usual options are a home-sale contingency in your Florida offer, a bridge loan, or a home equity line opened on your current home before you list it. Each has costs and risks, and we should weigh them against your numbers.
Can I qualify with a new Florida job, or if I keep working remotely?
Often, yes. A signed, non-contingent offer letter can be usable in some cases, with employer verification and sometimes extra reserves until your start date. If you're keeping a remote job, tell me early: lenders verify that the employment and income continue after you move.
Can I close on a Florida home without flying down?
Many buyers do. Depending on the lender, the title company and the loan program, you may be able to sign with a mobile notary near you or by remote online notarization. I attend inspections in person and walk you through every home live on video before you make an offer.
More detail: how remote buying works · loan options
Ryan Solberg, MLO NMLS #1784218 · Mortgageinc NMLS #2028516 · Equal Housing Opportunity. All loans are subject to credit approval and underwriting. This is general information, not a commitment to lend.
One Team for the Home and the Loan
Find your Florida home and your mortgage from Buffalo.
I'm both a Florida broker and a licensed mortgage loan originator. For an out-of-state move that matters, because the home search and the financing have to line up: when you sell in Buffalo, when you close here, and what you can offer in between.
- Pre-qualify before you fly down, so the homes we tour fit your budget.
- Compare loan options side by side: conventional, FHA, VA and jumbo.
- Plan the timing if you need to buy in Florida before your Buffalo home sells.
- See the full monthly payment, including Florida taxes and insurance, before you write an offer.
Ryan Solberg, MLO NMLS #1784218 · Mortgageinc NMLS #2028516 · Equal Housing Opportunity. Not a commitment to lend. You are never required to use Ryan's lending services to work with him as your agent.
Live MLS Inventory
Homes for sale in Central Florida right now.
Browse active homes for sale in Orlando, Central Florida, sourced from Stellar MLS. Current inventory includes single-family homes, condos, and waterfront properties across a range of price points.
$525,000
ActiveORLANDO, FL 32839
Residential
MLS# O6448195
$275,000
ActiveORLANDO, FL 32808
Residential
MLS# O6413330
$650,000
ActiveORLANDO, FL 32827
Residential
MLS# G5115052
$320,000
ActiveORLANDO, FL 32806
Residential
MLS# O6454659
$298,000
ActiveORLANDO, FL 32828
Residential
MLS# O6441240
$480,000
ActiveORLANDO, FL 32837
Residential
MLS# O6446092
Listings courtesy of Stellar MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Data deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Common Questions
Moving from Buffalo to Florida: questions I get most.
How much will I save in taxes moving from New York to Florida?
+
Florida has no state income tax, and New York's graduated rates run up to 10.9%. On $100,000 of taxable income, a single filer pays New York roughly $5,000 to $5,500 a year. A married couple on $200,000 pays roughly $10,500 to $12,000. Unlike New York City, Buffalo has no city income tax, so that's most of the saving. New York also has an estate tax, and Florida doesn't. These are 2026 estimates, not tax advice, so confirm with a CPA.
Do I still owe New York tax after I move to Florida?
+
You'll file a part-year New York return for the year you move. After that, New York can still tax income from New York sources, and it audits people who change domicile, asking for clear and convincing evidence. Keeping a Buffalo home and spending more than 183 days in New York can also make you a statutory resident. Move your license, voter registration, doctors and daily life, and talk to a New York tax professional.
Will moving from Buffalo to Florida save me taxes in retirement?
+
Less than you might expect on some income. New York doesn't tax Social Security, and it exempts New York public and federal pensions. It also excludes up to $20,000 a year of private pension and IRA income once you're 59½. The bigger savings come with larger IRA withdrawals, investment income or an estate near New York's estate tax threshold. Florida taxes none of these at the state level. Check your own numbers with a CPA.
Are Florida property taxes lower than in Erie County?
+
Usually, yes. New York averages about 1.3% of home value and Florida about 0.8%, and many Erie County towns run higher once school taxes are added. Florida's homestead exemption and Save Our Homes cap reduce a primary home's bill further. A home you buy is taxed on its new assessed value, not the seller's bill, so I'll estimate the real number for every home we look at.
How much is homeowners insurance in Orlando compared with Buffalo?
+
In NAIC's 2023 data, the average New York homeowners premium was $1,801 a year and Florida's was $2,779 statewide. Actual quotes vary far more than that. Roof age, construction and wind-mitigation features drive the price, and older homes often need a four-point inspection. Flood coverage is a separate policy. I get insurance quotes on your finalists before the inspection period ends.
Which Orlando neighborhoods feel most like Buffalo?
+
If you love the Elmwood Village or Parkside, College Park is the closest match, with older bungalows and a walkable main street, typically $500K to $1.2M. Winter Garden's Plant Street has the village-center feel of East Aurora, at about $450K to $900K. For the Clarence or Orchard Park mix of space and newer homes, look at Clermont or St. Cloud, usually $350K to $700K.
What's the best route and how many days is the drive from Buffalo to Orlando?
+
It's about 1,170 miles and roughly 17 to 18 hours of driving without stops, so most people take two days. A common route is I-90 to Erie, I-79 and I-77 south through West Virginia toward Charlotte, then I-26 and I-95 into Florida and I-4 to Orlando. Southern Virginia or the Charlotte area makes a sensible overnight stop. In winter, check lake-effect forecasts before you leave.
When is the best time to move from Buffalo to Florida?
+
Fall usually works best. You beat the first big lake-effect storms, movers are past the summer rush, and you arrive as Central Florida's dry season starts. Hurricane season runs June 1 to November 30, and insurers can pause new policies when a storm threatens, so a closing after November is less likely to hit that snag. If you want the larger homestead exemption under Amendment 3, the residency date that matters is December 31, 2026, so talk to me about timing now.
Do I have to be a Florida resident by December 31, 2026 to get the bigger homestead exemption?
+
Under Amendment 3, approved in November 2026, people who are permanent Florida residents by December 31, 2026 can qualify for a non-school exemption of up to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028. Later arrivals start with a $25,000 school exemption plus a $50,000 non-school exemption, and get the larger amount from their fifth year. Paperwork alone doesn't create residency. The Legislature still has to write the rules, so confirm with the property appraiser.
Should I rent first or buy right away when moving from Buffalo?
+
If you know Central Florida and the area you want, buying right away avoids rent and a second move. If you've only visited in February, a 6–12 month lease lets you live through a summer and test commutes first. Renting can still establish Florida residency. Either way, get preapproved early so you're ready when the right home comes up.
Meet Ryan
Work with a Central Florida specialist who knows every neighborhood.
More Relocation Resources
Moving from somewhere else? See every city and country guide+
Alabama
Alaska
California
District of Columbia
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Missouri
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
South Carolina
South Dakota
Texas
Utah
Free live session every Tuesday at 7 pm ET
Moving to Central Florida 101: the real monthly cost, line by line
Tue, Nov 17 · 7:00 pm ET · 40 minutes with Ryan Solberg
Start the conversation
Tell me where you're coming from and what you're building toward.
I help buyers relocating from Buffalo and across New Yorkfind the right home in Central Florida and line up the mortgage to go with it. Tell me your timeline, your budget and how you want to live, and I'll come back with a specific neighborhood and property strategy, not a Zillow link.
321.373.3536Live the MaxLife.
Request your relocation call
Tell me what you're selling in Western New York and what your first Florida winter should look like.