Buyer guide

New construction
vs. resale homes
in Orlando.

Both have real advantages and real gotchas. Here's the unvarnished breakdown of what each path actually looks like in the Central Florida market — from a broker who transacts in both.

Ryan Solberg · Florida Real Estate Broker · $85M+ in career closings · Orlando, FL

When to buy new construction

  • You want a warranty, modern systems, and specific customization
  • You're anchored to a master-planned community (Lake Nona, Horizon West)
  • You can absorb a 6–14 month build wait
  • You'll use the builder's preferred lender for rate buydown incentives

When to buy resale

  • You need to close in 30–45 days (job relocation, school year)
  • You want established Dr. Phillips, Windermere, or Winter Park character
  • You want to avoid CDD fees on top of your mortgage
  • You want full inspection rights and price negotiation flexibility

Factor by factor

The full tradeoff breakdown.

FactorNew ConstructionResaleEdge
Price negotiabilityLimited on price; negotiate through incentives (rate buydowns, credits)Full negotiation on price, credits, repairs, and termsResale

More levers available in resale negotiation

CDD feesCommon in master-planned areas ($1,500–$5,000+/year)Varies; often none in established Dr. Phillips/WindermereResale

CDD significantly increases carrying cost

TimelineSpec: 30–60 days · To-build: 6–14 months30–45 days (financed), 14–21 days (cash)Resale

Faster and more predictable

CustomizationDesign center options (flooring, cabinets, counters) within builder packagesRenovate post-close; full control, unlimited scopeNew Construction

Built-in personalization during construction

Warranty coverageBuilder warranty (1-year workmanship, 2-year systems, 10-year structural)Optional home warranty; older systems carry more riskNew Construction

Significant peace of mind for major systems

Neighborhood characterActive construction around you for years; uniform new aestheticEstablished character, mature trees, known neighborsResale

Buyers often underestimate construction disruption

Energy efficiencyModern insulation, HVAC zoning, impact windows standardDepends on vintage; pre-2000 homes may need upgradesNew Construction

Lower utility costs and insurance in some cases

Inspection flexibilityBuilder controls access; independent inspector at key milestonesFull inspection; seller must respond to findingsResale

More protection and more remedies available

Appraisal riskSparse comps in new communities; appraisal can lag list priceEstablished comp base; appraisals more predictableResale

New construction appraisal issues can delay closing

Builder incentives$10K–$50K in rate buydowns, closing credits, upgrades (end-of-phase deals)Seller concessions possible; less structuredNew Construction

Builder incentive packages can be substantial

If you go new construction

Six things to do before you sign.

01

Hire a buyer's agent first

Before you walk into any model home. The builder's on-site agent works for the builder. Bring your own representation — it costs you nothing (builder pays).

02

Get pre-approved for financing

Builder's preferred lender often offers better rate buydowns — compare their package against the open market before committing.

03

Negotiate incentives, not price

Builders protect list price to preserve future comp values. Focus on rate buydowns, closing cost credits, and design center upgrades.

04

Hire an independent inspector

At framing, pre-drywall, and final walkthrough. Builder-contracted inspectors answer to the builder. Yours answers to you.

05

Read the contract — all 60 pages

Builder contracts heavily favor the builder. Understand the earnest money schedule, change order costs, and delay clauses before signing.

06

Calculate your true all-in cost

List price + CDD fees + HOA + design upgrades + closing costs. New construction true all-in cost is often 8–15% above list price.

Common questions

What buyers ask most.

Is new construction or resale cheaper in Orlando in 2026?
It depends on the submarket and the builder. In active master-planned communities like Lake Nona, Horizon West, and Celebration, new construction from national builders (Toll Brothers, Pulte, Meritage) is priced 5–15% above comparable resale in the same community — builders are less willing to negotiate in a supply-constrained market. However, new construction often comes with builder incentives (rate buydowns, closing cost contributions, design center credits) that can close that gap by 3–5%. In established neighborhoods like Dr. Phillips and Windermere, resale is typically the only option — there's no vacant land for new builds in most gated communities.
What are CDD fees and do new construction homes in Orlando have them?
CDD (Community Development District) fees are a recurring annual charge on your property tax bill — they fund the roads, utilities, stormwater systems, and amenities in master-planned communities. Most new construction in Orlando's master-planned areas (Lake Nona, Horizon West, Celebration, Laureate Park) carries CDD fees ranging from $1,500 to $5,000+ per year. Early phase buyers in a new development pay the highest CDD fees because bonds are freshly issued; late-phase or resale buyers in the same community may have lower or nearly retired bonds. Always ask for the current CDD annual amount and the payoff schedule before closing.
Can I negotiate the price on a new construction home in Orlando?
Yes, but differently than resale. Builders rarely budge on list price — cutting their own comp would hurt future lot sales. Instead, they negotiate through incentives: mortgage rate buydowns (often 1–2 points), closing cost contributions ($10,000–$30,000), design center credits (appliance upgrades, flooring upgrades), and lot premium reductions. The best time to negotiate with a builder is end of quarter or end of year when they're trying to close out phase inventory. A buyer's agent experienced with builders can extract more in incentives than most buyers get on their own — and the agent's fee typically comes from the builder, not the buyer.
How long does it take to close on a new construction home in Orlando?
For spec homes (already under construction or complete), 30–60 days from contract. For to-be-built (you pick the lot and customize), typically 6–14 months depending on the builder and stage of construction. During the build, most builders require periodic inspections — you'll want an independent inspector at framing, pre-drywall, and final walkthrough stages. Resale typically closes in 30–45 days (financed) or 14–21 days (cash).
What are the advantages of buying resale over new construction in Orlando?
Key resale advantages: (1) Established neighborhoods with mature trees and known community character — you can see exactly what you're buying. (2) No CDD fees in most established Dr. Phillips, Windermere, and Winter Park communities. (3) Faster closing — 30–45 days vs. 6–14 months for new builds. (4) More negotiation flexibility — motivated sellers will accept inspection requests, price reductions, and credits that builders typically won't. (5) Known resale comps — appraisals are cleaner because there's a deep history of comparable sales. (6) No construction disruption — in an active new-build community, your neighbors may be under construction for years.
Do I need a buyer's agent for new construction in Orlando?
Yes — and the builder pays the buyer's agent commission in most cases. The builder's on-site sales agent represents the builder, not you. Having your own agent means someone is in your corner reviewing the contract (builder contracts heavily favor the builder), negotiating incentives you might not know to ask for, coordinating independent inspections, and advocating during the build process. Not bringing your own agent doesn't save money — the builder keeps that commission. Bring representation.

Ready to decide?

Tell me what you need. I'll tell you which path.

Ryan represents buyers in both new construction and resale transactions — and won't steer you toward one just because it's what's available. A 15-minute call is worth more than any guide.