Reserve at Lake Butler Sound
Windermere's intimate lakefront enclave on Lake Butler.
Live the MaxLife.
$3.5M
Median Price
$2M – $15M
150
Homes
$400–$400
Monthly HOA
1998
Established
Windermere Elementary School
School Zone
Search Homes for Sale in Reserve at Lake Butler Sound
Stellar MLS · 2026-04-26 · 1 closed sale
Recent market data
Median sold
$1,330,000
$1330K – $1330K
Median DOM
115
days on market
First access
Get notified when a Reserve at Lake Butler Sound home hits the market.
VIP members see new Reserve at Lake Butler Sound inventory 48 hours before Zillow.
Background
A brief history
The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound opened in the late 1990s on a piece of Lake Butler shoreline that had been held by a single family for most of the century. Only about 150 lots were ever platted — many of them oversized on the lakefront — which is why the community has remained deliberately small and quiet relative to Isleworth and Keene's Pointe. The original intent was a low-density lakefront community with one guarded entrance and minimal interior streets. That core concept has held. Build-out was largely complete by the mid-2010s, and most turnover since then has been either resales or selective teardowns on the largest lakefront lots.
The feel
What it's like to live here
The Reserve is the neighborhood most clients describe as 'feels like a private estate, not a subdivision.' The community is small enough that everyone recognizes each other. Streets are wide and sparsely homed — you'll often see more cranes and egrets on a morning walk than cars. Lot sizes are a defining feature: most lots are 0.75 to 2 acres, with lakefront parcels running up to 3-plus acres and multiple hundred feet of frontage. The architecture is overwhelmingly custom Mediterranean and transitional-contemporary, with a smaller share of Georgian. Most homes have private docks and boat lifts on Lake Butler — which, as the largest and deepest lake in the Butler Chain, supports skiing and wakeboarding and connects via canal to Lake Louise, Lake Isleworth, and the rest of the chain.
The details
What to expect
Architecture & Lots
Custom Mediterranean, transitional-contemporary, and Georgian. Main houses 5,500–12,000 square feet. Lots run 0.75 to 3 acres. Almost all lakefront lots include a private dock and boat lift. Architectural review board approval required for all exterior changes.
Lake Butler Access
Lake Butler is approximately 1,660 acres, the largest and deepest in the Butler Chain. Deep enough to support skiing, wakesurfing, and serious bass fishing. The chain is navigable to six other connected lakes via canals. Idle-speed zones apply near docks and in the canals. The Butler Chain is a state-designated Outstanding Florida Water — expect stricter dock-building rules than other local lakes.
HOA Rules & Fees
Monthly HOA: $400 (confirmed via public HOA data, Apr 2026 — tjcosgrove.com/Sentry Management). Covers 24-hr guard, private roads, and security. Single manned gate at the main entrance. Dock modifications require both HOA and St. Johns River Water Management District approval (allow 8–12 weeks total). No short-term rentals; 60-day minimum lease in most sections.
Schools
Zoned for Windermere Elementary, Bridgewater Middle, and Olympia High — same assignment as Keene's Pointe and most of Windermere. Windermere Prep is under 10 minutes; The First Academy is about 15 minutes.
Access & Commute
Entrance off Conroy-Windermere Road. Eight minutes to Restaurant Row, 25 minutes to downtown Orlando, 30 minutes to MCO, 15 minutes to Disney. Quick access to the 429 via Conroy-Windermere.
Community
Amenities
- Private docks and boat lifts on most lakefront lots
- Direct Lake Butler access — gateway to the full Butler Chain
- 24-hour manned gate
- Oversized lots (0.75–3 acres)
- Community walking paths and lakefront sunset park
Know Before You Buy
HOA rules worth knowing
- HOA: $400/month — confirmed Apr 2026 (Sentry Management, 352-243-4596 ext. 59008)
- Covers 24-hr guard, private roads, security
- Dock modifications require HOA + SJRWMD approval (8–12 weeks)
- Short-term rentals prohibited; 60-day minimum lease
- All exterior changes subject to ARB review
- Outstanding Florida Water restrictions on lake activity
Education
School assignments
- Windermere Elementary School
- Chain of Lakes Middle School
- Olympia High School
- Windermere Prep (private)
- The First Academy (private)
School zone assignments change. Verify with Orange County Public Schools before purchase.
Market Commentary
What the market is doing
Median sale currently sits in the $3M–$4M band, with non-lakefront interior homes trading from $2M and true lakefront estates crossing $10M–$15M on the upper end. Lake Butler frontage is the single biggest driver — a waterfront lot typically doubles the value of a comparable interior lot in the same community. Inventory is thin. In a typical year you'll see six to twelve transactions total, and off-market activity is common for the top tier. Days-on-market averages 45–75 days; lakefront can take longer simply because the pool of qualified buyers is smaller.
Active MLS Inventory
Search homes in Reserve at Lake Butler Sound
Live MLS search for Reserve at Lake Butler Sound is coming online shortly.
In the meantime, get notified when a home in Reserve at Lake Butler Sound hits the market — VIP list members see new Reserve at Lake Butler Sound inventory 48 hours before it appears on Zillow.
Get Reserve at Lake Butler Sound AlertsActive MLS Inventory
Homes available in Reserve at Lake Butler Sound
4 homes currently listed in Reserve at Lake Butler Sound.
$1,529,999
11015 Hawkshead Ct
Windermere, FL 34786
5 bd · 5 ba · 3,868 sqft
Reserve At Lake Butler Sound
MLS# O6405977
$2,300,000
6550 Cartmel Ln
Windermere, FL 34786
4 bd · 5 ba · 4,257 sqft
Reserve At Lake Butler Sound
MLS# O6396111
$13,000 /mo
11051 Coniston Way
Windermere, FL 34786
5 bd · 6 ba · 5,498 sqft
Reserve At Lake Butler Sound
MLS# O6392514
$1,895,000
11051 Hawkshead Ct
Windermere, FL 34786
5 bd · 6 ba · 3,728 sqft
Reserve At Lake Butler Sound
MLS# O6400963
Also Worth Seeing
Related communities
Windermere
Isleworth
Arnold Palmer's Windermere legacy — Florida's most private address.
$2M – $40M · 660 homes
Explore Isleworth →
Windermere
Keene's Pointe
Windermere's guard-gated Jack Nicklaus community on the Butler Chain.
$900K – $5M · 1,100 homes
Explore Keene's Pointe →
Butler Chain of Lakes
Lake Tibet-Butler Homes
The quieter Butler Chain lake — still connected, still skiable.
$2M – $6M · 200 homes
Explore Lake Tibet-Butler Homes →
Want Reserve at Lake Butler Sound homes first?
Hand-picked Reserve at Lake Butler Sound matches — 48 hours before MLS. Two to three per month.
Listings courtesy of Stellar MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of June 3, 2026. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.
Ryan Solberg, Broker · MaxLife Realty LLC · FL License #BK3354351 · Equal Housing Opportunity · Full disclaimer · DMCA
