Bay Hill
Arnold Palmer's home course community, just off Restaurant Row.
Live the MaxLife.
$1.1M
Median Price
$500K – $5M
1,600
Homes
$45–$1308
Monthly HOA
1961
Established
Dr. Phillips Elementary School
School Zone
Search Homes for Sale in Bay Hill
Stellar MLS · 2026-04-26 · 8 closed sales
Recent market data
Median sold
$1,622,500
$724K – $2560K
$/sqft
$445
Median DOM
86
days on market
First access
Get notified when a Bay Hill home hits the market.
VIP members see new Bay Hill inventory 48 hours before Zillow.
Background
A brief history
Bay Hill is older than most people realize — the original plats go back to 1961, when the community was laid out around a new Dick Wilson golf course on the shores of the Butler Chain. Arnold Palmer first came through in 1965 for an exhibition, bought into the course in 1970, and purchased it outright in 1976. He lived in Bay Hill until his death in 2016, and his family still owns the club. The PGA's Arnold Palmer Invitational has been played here since 1979, and the week of the tournament every March remains the most defining event on the neighborhood's calendar. Because Bay Hill pre-dates the master-planned-community era, its home stock spans six decades — original 1960s ranches sit alongside 1980s custom Mediterraneans, 2000s rebuilds, and a growing share of transitional contemporary teardowns completed in the last five years.
The feel
What it's like to live here
Bay Hill is the community that feels most like old-Florida luxury rather than new-money gated. It's non-gated — something longtime residents prize and first-time visitors are sometimes surprised by. Streets wind around the Arnold Palmer-designed course and Big Sand Lake, with a dense canopy of live oaks shading most of the interior. Lots range from quarter-acre to over an acre, and the tournament-week vibe is its own thing — expect street closures, valet setups at the club, corporate hospitality tents, and a general increase in ambient energy for about ten days every March. Residents either love it or plan their annual vacation around it. Big Sand Lake access is through several community easements and private docks; boats range from pontoons to ski boats, with the main usable lake area concentrated on the south side of the course.
The details
What to expect
Architecture & Lots
Six decades of home stock. 1960s–1970s ranches (often teardown candidates). 1980s–1990s custom Mediterraneans. 2000s–2010s rebuilds. A growing share of 2020s transitional and modern contemporary new builds. Lots 0.25 to 1 acre. Expect wide architectural variety even within the same street.
Lifestyle & Amenities
Bay Hill Club & Lodge (separate membership) offers the Arnold Palmer-designed championship course, tennis, fitness, pool, marina on Big Sand Lake, and 70-room lodge. The Arnold Palmer Invitational runs every March and reshapes the neighborhood for a week. Residents enjoy a historic marina, boat slips, and direct Butler Chain access via Big Sand Lake.
HOA Rules & Fees
Bay Hill is non-gated with multiple independent sub-HOAs; dues range from $45/month (minimal sections) to $1,308/month (waterfront or Sanctuary sub-sections), confirmed via public listing data, Apr 2026. Most interior sections run $100–$300/month. Some sub-sections have architectural review; others don't. Short-term rentals are allowed in most sections — peak during API tournament week.
Schools
Zoned for Dr. Phillips Elementary, Southwest Middle, and Dr. Phillips High (Visual & Performing Arts magnet). Private options include The First Academy and Orlando Jewish Day School within 10 minutes.
Access & Commute
Three minutes to Restaurant Row, 20 minutes to downtown Orlando, 15 minutes to Disney, 25 minutes to MCO. I-4 access via the Sand Lake Road or Palm Parkway on-ramps. Tournament week: plan on 10-minute delays on Apopka-Vineland and Bay Hill Boulevard.
Community
Amenities
- Bay Hill Club & Lodge — Arnold Palmer-designed championship course
- Host of the PGA's Arnold Palmer Invitational every March
- Marina and boat slips on Big Sand Lake
- Butler Chain of Lakes access
- Walking distance to Restaurant Row
- Historic 1960s-founded community with mature tree canopy
Know Before You Buy
HOA rules worth knowing
- Non-gated community — multiple independent sub-HOAs; dues $45–$1,308/month confirmed via listing data, Apr 2026
- Interior sections typically $100–$300/month; waterfront and Sanctuary sub-sections up to $1,308/month
- Short-term rentals generally permitted; peak demand during API tournament week in March
- Some sub-sections have architectural review; others do not — verify the specific section before offer
- Club membership (Bay Hill Club & Lodge) is separate from homeownership
- Tournament-week parking and traffic restrictions apply annually
Education
School assignments
- Dr. Phillips Elementary School
- Southwest Middle School
- Dr. Phillips High School
- The First Academy (private)
- Orlando Jewish Day School (private)
School zone assignments change. Verify with Orange County Public Schools before purchase.
Market Commentary
What the market is doing
Bay Hill's median sits around $900K–$1.2M, which is genuinely broad — the neighborhood has homes trading from $500K for smaller ranch originals up to $5M+ for fairway-frontage new builds. The three biggest value drivers are: golf frontage (direct fairway views add 15–25%), Big Sand Lake access, and whether the home has been renovated to current luxury standards (most 1960s–1980s originals need substantial work). Tournament-week short-term rentals are a known sub-market — some owners rent for API week and cover a meaningful share of their annual holding costs. Price-per-square-foot spread is wide: $225 for dated originals, $450+ for new custom builds.
Active MLS Inventory
Search homes in Bay Hill
Live MLS search for Bay Hill is coming online shortly.
In the meantime, get notified when a home in Bay Hill hits the market — VIP list members see new Bay Hill inventory 48 hours before it appears on Zillow.
Get Bay Hill AlertsActive MLS Inventory
Homes available in Bay Hill
2 homes currently listed in Bay Hill.
Also Worth Seeing
Related communities
Dr. Phillips
Phillips Bay
A gated Dr. Phillips condo and townhome community on Spring Lake.
$280K – $650K · 200 homes
Explore Phillips Bay →
Dr. Phillips
Orange Tree
Dr. Phillips' established family neighborhood with mature oak canopy.
$500K – $2.5M · 900 homes
Explore Orange Tree →
Dr. Phillips
Sand Lake Hills
The entry point to Dr. Phillips schools without the luxury premium.
$600K – $1.2M · 500 homes
Explore Sand Lake Hills →
Want Bay Hill homes first?
Hand-picked Bay Hill matches — 48 hours before MLS. Two to three per month.
Listings courtesy of Stellar MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of June 3, 2026. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.
Ryan Solberg, Broker · MaxLife Realty LLC · FL License #BK3354351 · Equal Housing Opportunity · Full disclaimer · DMCA