Heritage Isles
Golf community living with an approachable entry point in New Tampa
Live the MaxLife.
$470K
Median Price
$340K – $800K
1,000
Homes
$110–$160
Monthly HOA
1994
Established
Turner Elementary (K-5, GreatSchools 7/10, B)
School Zone
Search Homes for Sale in Heritage Isles
First access
Get notified when a Heritage Isles home hits the market.
VIP members see new Heritage Isles inventory 48 hours before Zillow.
Background
A brief history
Heritage Isles was developed starting in 1994 as part of the same wave of master-planned growth that defined New Tampa's northeast Hillsborough expansion. The community was built around the Heritage Isles Golf and Country Club, an 18-hole semi-private course designed by Arthur Hills that opened to play in 1995. Unlike Hunters Green to the south, Heritage Isles was conceived from the outset as a non-gated community — a deliberate choice by the developers to capture a broader price range and attract buyers who wanted golf-community ambiance without the premium and restrictions of a guard gate.
Through the late 1990s, Heritage Isles filled in with approximately 1,000 homes across several phases and product types, ranging from attached villas starting around 1,400 square feet to executive single-family homes exceeding 3,000 square feet on fairway lots. The community benefited directly from the parallel build-out of New Tampa's commercial infrastructure — the opening of Tampa Palms shopping centers, the expansion of USF's Health campus, and the arrival of major corporate employers in the I-75 corridor made the address increasingly attractive to the professional demographic the developers were targeting.
Heritage Isles weathered the 2008 housing cycle with some difficulty — the non-gated nature and broader price range meant more investor distress than in Hunters Green — but values recovered firmly through the 2013–2016 period as the Tampa Bay market normalized. Since 2020, the community has seen renewed demand from remote workers and USF-affiliated buyers, with median prices rising approximately 55 percent over a four-year span as inventory remained persistently low.
The feel
What it's like to live here
Heritage Isles has the feel of a well-established, unpretentious golf community where neighbors know each other and the community pool on a summer afternoon is more social event than lap-swim session. The absence of a guard gate gives the community a slightly more open, accessible character than Hunters Green — residents describe it as friendly rather than formal, and weekend activity on the golf course and trails confirms that the amenities are genuinely used rather than merely marketed. The lagoon-style pool with its waterslide is a genuine neighborhood hub, drawing families from across the community on warm weekends.
The buyer profile reflects the community's pricing: young families making their first move into a single-family home with resort amenities, USF faculty and staff drawn by proximity to campus, and Moffitt Cancer Center employees who want a quality school district without stretching into the Hunters Green price tier. There is also a notable contingent of long-term residents who bought in the late 1990s, are now empty nesters, and have chosen to stay because the golf access and community connections outweigh any reason to move.
The details
What to expect
Architecture
Heritage Isles homes were built primarily between 1994 and 2003 by a mix of national and regional builders including Centex, US Home, and several custom-production builders, resulting in more architectural variety than you find in a single-builder community. Mediterranean and Florida traditional styles dominate, with stucco and tile roofs throughout. Lot sizes skew slightly smaller than Hunters Green — 5,500 to 9,000 square feet is typical for single-family homes — and villa clusters are found on the northeast quadrant of the community. Many homes feature screened lanais, and golf-front homes frequently have extended pools and summer kitchens added by subsequent owners. Interior finishes on unrenovated homes reflect their mid-1990s origins, but the bones — roof trusses, block construction, concrete slab — are sound.
Lifestyle
Heritage Isles residents tend to be highly engaged with the community's physical amenities in ways that translate to a genuinely active outdoor lifestyle. Golf, walking trails, tennis, and pool time are the organizing rhythms of the week, and the community's HOA sponsors seasonal events — holiday golf scrambles, summer pool parties, food truck nights — that keep social connections active. The proximity to USF creates an unusually educated and globally diverse neighbor mix for a suburban Florida community. Grocery, dining, and retail needs are met within five minutes at the New Tampa and Tampa Palms commercial corridors, and the community's positioning inside the Pasco/Hillsborough county line means access to both counties' parks and recreation programming.
HOA Rules
Heritage Isles operates under a single master HOA with monthly dues ranging from $110 to $160 depending on unit type — considerably simpler than the layered structure in Hunters Green. The HOA covers common area maintenance, community amenity upkeep, and exterior landscaping standards. Unlike most Hillsborough County HOAs, Heritage Isles permits limited short-term rental activity (minimum 30 days) under the current documents, though enforcement varies and buyers should verify the current policy before purchasing with rental intent. Architectural changes require committee approval, and the standards are consistently applied. The non-gated nature means there is no gatehouse assessment, which partially explains the lower monthly dues relative to guard-gated communities.
Schools
The Heritage Isles school assignment feeds Turner Elementary, Bartels Middle, and Wharton High — a solid corridor that positions families well for college preparation. Wharton is the district's standout: its graduation rate exceeds 96 percent, its AP pass rates are consistently above state averages, and its dual-enrollment partnerships with Hillsborough Community College allow motivated students to enter college with 15–20 credit hours already completed. Turner Elementary has a dedicated gifted program (through the district's Gifted Resource Teacher model) and strong parental involvement metrics. Bartels Middle benefits from being a relatively newer facility with science labs and a performing arts program that feeds directly into Wharton's award-winning band and theater departments.
Access & Commute
Heritage Isles sits approximately 1 mile northeast of the Hunters Green entrance, positioning it slightly deeper into New Tampa but still within easy reach of the I-75 / Bruce B. Downs interchange. USF's main campus is roughly 9 miles via Bruce B. Downs, a straightforward 15–20 minute drive outside peak hours. Moffitt Cancer Center and the USF Health campus are 12 miles. Downtown Tampa is 22 miles and typically 30–40 minutes in morning commute traffic. The community is well-positioned for northward commutes to Wesley Chapel's growing employment base (BayCare, MetLife, Kforce) as well as southward travel toward Brandon and the I-4 corridor. There is no Sunrail or fixed-transit access, making car ownership essential.
Community
Amenities
- Heritage Isles Golf & Country Club — 18-hole semi-private Arthur Hills design
- Lagoon-style community pool with waterslide and zero-entry shallow end
- Lighted tennis courts (4 courts) and basketball courts
- Multi-use trails connecting residential phases and the golf course perimeter
- Community park with playground equipment and open green space
- Club restaurant and bar open to residents and members
- Multiple retention lake fishing areas throughout the community
- Proximity to New Tampa YMCA and Morris Bridge Road athletic fields
Education
School assignments
- Turner Elementary (K-5, GreatSchools 7/10, B)
- Bartels Middle School (6-8, GreatSchools 7/10, B)
- Wharton High School (9-12, GreatSchools 8/10, A)
School zone assignments change. Verify with Orange County Public Schools before purchase.
Market Commentary
What the market is doing
Heritage Isles offers some of the best value in the New Tampa golf community segment, and buyers who compare it directly to Hunters Green often find that the $50,000–$100,000 price differential is difficult to justify on pure quality-of-life grounds. Attached villas start in the low $340,000s and provide entry to the same school district and amenity package as homes priced twice as high on golf-front lots. Mid-range single-family homes — 1,800 to 2,400 square feet, typically on interior lots with lake or pond views — cluster between $400,000 and $550,000 and represent the core of the resale market. Premium product in Heritage Isles is defined by fairway frontage and square footage above 2,800 feet; those homes trade between $600,000 and $800,000 and have historically appreciated at the same rate as comparable Hunters Green product despite the lower base price. The semi-private club model means residents can purchase social or golf memberships independently rather than being embedded in a community-wide assessment structure, which reduces mandatory monthly costs but also means the club's long-term financial stability depends on external membership sales — a factor sophisticated buyers should evaluate before purchasing a fairway-front home.
Active MLS Inventory
Search homes in Heritage Isles
Live MLS search for Heritage Isles is coming online shortly.
In the meantime, get notified when a home in Heritage Isles hits the market — VIP list members see new Heritage Isles inventory 48 hours before it appears on Zillow.
Get Heritage Isles AlertsActive MLS Inventory
Homes available in Heritage Isles
1 home currently listed in Heritage Isles.
Also Worth Seeing
Related communities
Want Heritage Isles homes first?
Hand-picked Heritage Isles matches — 48 hours before MLS. Two to three per month.
Listings courtesy of Stellar MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of June 5, 2026. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.
Ryan Solberg, Broker · MaxLife Realty LLC · FL License #BK3354351 · Equal Housing Opportunity · Full disclaimer · DMCA